Showing posts with label Ric Flair. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ric Flair. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 30, 2025

Best Pro Wrestling Matches Superstar Sleeze Watched in 2025 (Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair, Keiji Mutoh, John Cena)

 Hey Yo Stud Muffins & Foxy Ladies, 

The MartMan is scheduled to become MartDad on March 5th of the New Year, but we all know about the best laid plans of mice & men, so plus or minus a couple weeks on that there date. Very exciting and something looked forward to my whole life and glad I am doing with my loving wife. 

I am going to dispense with the long preamble and just get down to business. This was my most prolific reviewing year since 2020-2021. I far exceeded my goal of 150 matches and am at 168 by my count. I am hoping to squeeze in a couple more before the end of the year up here in Quebec, Canada, but we will see family and life throws at me. Next year I am shooting for 50 matches reviewed by the end of the year, we shall see. 

These are not the best matches to take place in 2025 which I thought was a dire year for professional wrestling, but rather the best matches I watched and reviewed in 2025. I had 14 matches listed at 4.25 (B+) or better and those reviews will be included in full here. I have the four star honorable mentions preceding them. Enjoy and Happy New Year!



Four Star Honorable Mentions

Masahiro Chono & Hiroyoshi Tenzan vs Kensuke Sasaki & Hiroshi Hase. - NJPW 3/7/95

Keiji Mutoh vs Masahiro Chono - NJPW 8/12/95

Arn Anderson & Brian Pillman vs Sting & "Ric Flair" - WCW Halloween Havoc 1995

Yoji Anjoh & Yoshihiro Takayama vs Masahiro Chono & Hiroyoshi Tenzan - UWFI 11/25/95

Keiji Mutoh vs Masahiro Chono - NJPW 1/4/00

IWGP Heavyweight Champion Kensuke Sasaki vs Takahashi Iizuka - NJPW 7/20/00

Masahiro Chono vs Keiji Mutoh - NJPW DOME QUAKE 7/20/01

Genichiro Tenryu vs Taiyo Kea - AJPW 10/27/01

Keiji Muto vs Toshiaki Kawada - AJPW 7/13/03 - #1 Contender's Match

All Japan Triple Crown Champion Toshiaki Kawada vs Kensuke Sasaki - AJPW 1/16/05

Toshiaki Kawada vs Hiroyoshi Tenzan- NJPW 8/4/05

AJPW Triple Crown Champion Satoshi Kojima vs Kensuke Sasaki – AJPW 11/19/05

Brock Lesnar vs The Undertaker - WWE Hell In A Cell 2015

WWE Universal Champion Goldberg vs Brock Lesnar - WrestleMania XXXIII

Four & A Quarter Star Matches

WCW World Heavyweight Champion Hulk Hogan vs Ric Flair 

WCW Clash of the Champions August 1994

I watched this about 2-3 years ago and loved it. But I didnt have time to review after I watched it. I watched it back today and boy oh boy did I love it. I actually think this is a Top 10-20 Hulk Hogan match of all time and does not get nearly enough love. 

The Tonya Harding angle gets a lot of shit, but I think it was brilliant on two levels. The most obvious was giving Flair the knee to work on and Hogan to sell. This was the hook of the match when would Flair get to the knee. It was looming the entire match. The less obvious but more important it was the reason for Hogan's rage. Hogan just beat Flair at the Bash at the Beach. What reason did he have to do anything different than Bash? Flair trying not just to take his title away but his career away with a nefarious, dastardly attack that will piss him off. Way too much is made of Hogan not selling enough to begin with. That's hogwash. Hogan was full of piss & vinegar because he was enraged. He saw red, brutha. This is was the appropriate reaction to such an attack. 

This is a perfect "How" match. It is a very simple layout, but it is all about Hogan's charisma and Flair's charisma that take this simple layout makes it so engrossing and thrilling. The simple layout is the babyface shine of Hogan exacting his revenge on Flair and just kicking all sorts of ass. Flair eventually gets a hold of the knee and then we get the finish. Each of these three segments come off pitch perfect.

Hogan's babyface shine is one of the all-time great babyface shines. He really lets it fly. He is pissed off and aint afraid to show it. He is throwing everything at Flair. Punches, pulling the robe over his head, stuffing his bandana in his mouth, kicking his ass on the outside. It is just a thrilling beating. Flair is a master of selling this for Hogan and making him look like a million bucks. This is one of the most enraged Hogan performances youll see and the way he does it is so entertaining. I love the two Flair hope spots: eyerake that leads to the Press Slam and then delayed vertical suplex into the Hogan no-sell was such a fist-pumping, chest-pounding highspot. 

Man when it came time for Flair to get his heat, he absolutely ripped into the knee. He worked it like a champ. Every stomp, crashing down with all his weight. It looked awesome. Just as Flair sold his ass off for Hogan, Hogan returned in kind for Flair. I loved the struggle over the first figure-4, but it was just a matter of time. The Hulk-Up out of the first Figure-4 is just money. This is Kobashi fighting Takayama with one arm in the year 2000 levels of awesomeness. The Hobbling Hulk-Up is one of the most badass Hulk-Ups of all time. He is fighting through the pain and just barely gets the leg up for the Big Boot as it buckles on him after impact. The Leg Drop is nuclear! It felt like he overcame all the pain in the world to jump as high as he ever did, crushed Flair, but is totally spent. Then Flair puts the Figure-4 back on! HIGH DRAMA! God Almighty this is so fucking awesome! I get the finish you cant really put the belt back on Flair and Hogan winning doesnt make sense. I like a countout more than DQ so Hogan getting attacked by Sherri and crumpling to the floor for the ten count was a serviceable finish. The Mystery Man who is clearly Arn Anderson, but it seems like they might be trying to sell it as Curt Hennig, comes out to help Flair beatdown Hulkster, but because Savage is not in the territory yet, we get the Stinger making the save. I dont like Beefcake but this was a perfect angle to retrocon him in as the mystery assailant.

This match felt like a Hogan Street Fight match on order of his other classic brawls with Kamala, Harley Race and Sgt. Slaughter. First I am a sucker for a street fight, but especially like when a "normal" match breaks down into a brawl and the ref just lets it all fly. This felt hot and like Hogan was out for blood. Hogan selling the knee through the comeback was a chef's kiss. Flair is the GOAT and just knocked it out the park. LOVE This Match! 

Yoshihisa Yamamoto vs Dick Vrij - RINGS 7/18/95

Imagine instead of being a lame spooky ass Aleister Black was a Dutch Kickboxing Badass like Dick Vrij! I’d be his biggest fan. 

This fucking ruled so hard. Dick Vrij is allergic to the mat. As soon as Yamamoto grabs a leg; he grabs the ropes. There is literally no grappling or submission work because Vrij is scared shitless of it. His whole strategy is to swing for the fences and knock out Yamamoto. In RINGS you charged for rope escapes so Yamamoto just needs to get 10 to win the match. There is one Shoot Knee that is BRUTAL~! Yamamoto shoots for the takedown BANG~! Knee Right to the Face! I don’t know how he was not legit knocked out. RED CARD~! Damn never seen that before charged a Down! Yamamoto tags Vrij pretty good causing a mouse under the eye which eventually opens up a the blood trickle adds so much. Besides one Down by Vrij, Yamamoto is just running up the score. I love Vrij’s selling down the stress. He looks like a worn down Terminator just hell bent on knocking out Yamamoto but knows he doesn’t have it in him. A yellow card and one last rope break wins the day for Yamamoto. Wicked entertaining match! Wish more wrestling was like this!

Keiji Mutoh vs Ric Flair - NJPW 8/13/95 G-1 Climax

Been watching a lot of Shining Wizard Mutoh rewinding back to Friar Tuck Mutoh. Within a couple minutes, you just know this will be good. Then the match keeps going and im like this is really damn good. By the end I am like this is fucking excellent why does no one talk about this match? I am loving finding a Flair performance I haven’t seen before that still gets me jazzed up. 

Flair encroaching on Mutoh’s space early and Mutoh taking time to hit three sides of the Ring before locking up was great psychology. Flair going down to the Knucklelock like he was facing the Hulkster did scare me BUT when Flair started working that all my fears & anxieties were allayed. We were all getting the Nature Boy! WOOOOOO! This is what all the Flair haters want a dominant Flair on top that works his opponent tough. Watch this match. He takes the majority of the match. The arm work is stellar. He works three different wrist locks, a hammerlock and some really good arm wringers. It is just beautiful NWA Championship style wrestling.

He paces the match wonderfully letting Mutoh pop the crowd with uptempo offense, selling that he is overwhelmed but then finding ways to come back. After the Arm work they work a great rope running sequence where Flair sets way too early on a monkey flip and Mutoh evades and dropkicks Flair out the Ring. Flair switches gears and just starts punching Mutoh in the corner crowding him suffocating him. Mutoh is able to rally and the Flair Flip bump to the floor really sends Flair into desperation mode. I LOVE that Flair reaction to this is putting Mutoh into figure-4. No frills. Just go for the kill shot. I love that instead of being climax that just leads to more leg work At this point, as a big Flair fan I am just gobbling this up. He is working more in control than usual, he is feeding hope spots at the right time. Mutoh who is very mercurial wrestler is wrestling like a great White meat babyface and showing fire and vulnerability each in the right moments. 

Man after the super plex when all of sudden there is blood streaming down Mutoh’s face and he goes into Stinger in Greensboro mode the match elevates to excellent. He runs through his big offense you think he is going to win with a Backbreaker moonsault BUT he crashes & burns! SO FLAIR WORKS THE CUT! MUTOH IS SPORTING A FULL CRIMSON MASK! Flair turns into like best boxer in the world some amazing punches! Flair re-applies Figure-4 on the bloody Mutoh and the visual is insane! I was losing my mind. Mutoh goes full Great Muta but if Great Muta was a babyface. His Hulk Up with all the blood is like he is fucking Terminator. I wish he really tore into Flair there but Moonsault win was still awesome!

Honestly if it was anyone else we would be ranting and raving about this match but it is Flair and it is such an embarrassment of riches still like this gets overlooked. It is a very good match that becomes a blood-soaked, fist-pumping triumph. Excellent Flair performance and Mutoh shines at the end.

Wild Pegasus vs Lord Steven Regal - NJPW 9/23/95

A skill vs will match. That is not to say Benoit does not have mat skills or Regal did not have the will to win BUT it was Regal’s mat skills that allowed him to press his advantage and it was Benoit’s rabid wolverine tenacity that kept him in it. I was surprised this match happened in Japan as there was a rather strict hierarchy between heavyweights and juniors. I don’t know why it was apparent to me in this match but how much bigger Regal was both height and width than Benoit. That size advantage also played a role in Regal’s strategy but also in the story of Benoit’s pugnacity overcoming the size disadvantage.

I am very much a narrative driven fan of pro wrestling. This is my favorite type of wrestling that is not narrative driven. It is very much a BattlArts ground based match. Both wrestlers especially Regal would have excelled in BatBat. Even for Benoit, having him work the mat for 12 minutes is unique. I would argue he looks better than Bret would in this setting. What keeps this compelling without the trappings of hooks and plot points is how much struggle and competitive it all is. I had the pleasure of watching Thatcher and Gulak do their thing in Lowell in October of this year thats what this was. There’s not as much to review from a beat to beat but is sporting competitive feel that wrestling promoters claim they are presenting and wrestling fans claim they want but so rarely do we actually get. As a fan of character-based and narrative-driven pro wrestling, I’d only want see one or two matches like this a card not every match.

The grappling was really high quality. So much struggle and urgency. The short palm strikes by Regal. The desperation he held onto wrist control from Benoit’s counters. Benoit really cool entry into the Short Arn Scissors. It is a very Lo-fi match and I’d argue there are no high spots for about 12 minutes. Benoit flips Regal over the top on a monkey flip exchange. Benoit draws blood from Regal’s ear bashing it against the post. The chops and the Headbutts to the ear ensue. We get some high impact suplexes the swan dive Headbutt. Great Regal selling of the ear but is it great selling if it hurts? 1995 Benoit loved the Tombstone but only two. Regal sits down on tops rope sunset flip anti-climatic for most matches but perfect for this Lo-fi classic.

A very cool unique match that really gets better with the blood. If it wasn’t for Benoit I’d give it a fullthroated recommendation but if you can stomach Benoit and love Lo-fi BatBat check this out.

Genichiro Tenryu vs Keiji Mutoh - AJPW 4/1/02

Just when you think you’ve seen all the Tenryu/Mutoh another one pops up on your radar. I thought this was a killer match not quite as good as the Classic 6/8/01 encounter or the WAR brawl but still an awesome match much better than their AJPW Triple Crown Match just 12 days later. 

The 6/8/01 starts off with a bang with the Shining Wizard that puts Tenryu in a deep hole. Here they lock up and Mutoh trips Tenryu on a rope break. Tenryu doesn’t take well to this slight and just starts lighting Mutoh up. Tenryu overcommits and leaves himself vulnerable to the counterattack. Dropkick to the Knee! BANG~! SHINING WIZARD! They got me hook, line and sinker. 

Tenryu powders. Mutoh goes for the kill shot a second Shining Wizard BUT WATS THE POST! Holy Shit! I fucking love it! He comes up bleeding so Tenryu pulls the timekeeper table over and blasts Mutoh in the head with it and he is really bleeding now. 

Tenryu works the cut and drops him on his head with a brainbuster. How have never seen this match before?!?

Mutoh tries some dropkicks to the knee. Tenryu clobbers with a clothesline and tries to reassert control with a Cravat. I love a Bloody Mutoh just ripping Dragon Leg Screws and throwing Dropkicks to the knee like his life depends on it. Mutoh eats a Potato. Tenryu tries desperately to end the match. Mutoh turns the clock back to the 90s with a back handspring elbow and Backbreaker. He absolutely blasted him with a Shining Wizard in there as well. Can Mutoh get the Moonsault. Nope Powerbomb! Mutoh roars back with a Kappou Kick. Tenryu looks discombobulated. He blocks a Shining Wizard. Lariat and Brainbuster! Tenryu wins!

The major plot points of this match hit so hard and they play off the 6/8/01 match so well. Mutoh is so committed to weakening the knee to set up Shining Wizard and also just rocking the head of Tenryu. Tenryu is the ornery old bastard working the cut, throwing tables and potatoes. Tenryu gets a crucial block and the Brainbuster. Two well-defined characters with key emphatic, consequential turning points that’s great pro wrestling. 

Four & A Half Star Matches

All Japan Triple Crown Champion Toshiaki Kawada vs Genichiro Tenryu - AJPW 1/18/04

I am surprised this match is so overlooked. You can chalk it up to post-split All Japan put they pulled in 10k+ at the Budokan for Kawada’s title defenses against Frye and Hashimoto. It feels like after the Hashimoto match that the gap between All Japan the big two of New Japan and NOAH widens to the point of no return but they were still doing healthy numbers at this point. This match features Two of the Big Three of Post-Split All Japan (Muto being the other of course). Their 2000 Triple Crown decision match is considered the classic but man I loved This one a whole lot. I need to rewatch that 2000 match because I think I am going crazy high on this. 

I don’t know if it is because I haven’t seen a match worked like this in a while but fucking loved this. It was like a 90s All Japan match but with a ton of hate. They waste no time getting right to it. On a rope break lights Kawada up with a chop and it is off to the races. Tenryu being the fucking prick that he is starts chopping high to the throat so Kawada responds with a fully loaded potato and trying to kick his idol’s head off with some absolutely savage kicks. Nobody sells having their bell ring better than Tenryu (maybe Brock). They fight over a suplex on the apron after a Tenryu powder when that doesn’t go Kawada’s way, he rears back and blasts Tenryu with another kick to the head. The last focus of Kawada just blasting Tenryu in the head with kicks was awesome. Tenryu starts throwing chairs in the Ring out frustration. 

I loved the transition. Kawada comes charging in for another head rocking kick but Tenryu swings around with an Enziguri to send the champion reeling. Tenryu rattles off three big bombs: Spider German, Mack Truck Lariat and a Powerbomb. Then there’s a cool wrinkle we get some inverted psychology. Normally you do Limb work to set up the bombs bur after his bombs dont get the job done, rather than panicking Tenryu reasserts control with some wicked awesome leg work on Kawada. Appreciated the Mutoh style dragon leg screws, he sure wrestled him enough over the last two years. Loved Kawada fighting off his back so Tenryu just lets him get up so he can light up with chops and potatoes. Kawada’s comeback is full of piss & vinegar. This isn’t like today strike exchanges, the is feels like a fight and they driving demolish the other. Kawada looks like he has Tenryu reeling but runs into a Brick Wall Lariat. He powders. In the spot of the match, Tenryu whips a chair at a young boy trying to help Kawada. Tenryu lariat and Brainbuster only get two. Powerbomb nothing doing. Kawada rolls through a DDT AND KICKS TENRYUS HEAD OFF! Jumping High Kick! DANGEROUS BACK DROP DRIVER! 1-2-No! I thought that should have been the finish. We get the Stretch Plum. Kawada rifling Tenryu with kicks. Tenryu showing dogged old man ornery resistance bur Kawada just keeps blasting him in the head and Brainbuster wins it. 

God Bless Tenryu for taking head kick after head kick. I loved that constant focus of Kawada’s offensive strategy to just kick Tenryu’s head off. There was a real piss & vinegar to this match. Both men were energized. The last 5 minutes were electric. Loved Tenryu’s control segment. Transitions were tight. This one never let up from jump. Loved it 

Kiyoshi Tamura vs Josh Barnett - U-Style 11/23/05

Man this is the best I have ever seen Barnett look in a pro wrestling ring. Tamura looked like it was 1995, shredded and a million bucks.

This match is definitely a match that rewards the viewer for going on the entire journey with them. The opening matwork was solid. They played into Barnett having the size advantage and because he is technically well rounded posed a real threat to Tamura. The selling on the wrist lock and then how Tamura fought like hell to maintain the clasp on the cross arm breaker attempt was awesome. Tamura burns a rope break there. It looks like Tamura is outgunned but in a standing scrum while Barnett was looking for a takedown…Tamura knees him in the head and the whole complexion of the match changes. 

All of sudden this accelerates into a classic territory. Barnetts response to suplex shit out of him was great. The second throw which was a German needs to be seen to be believed. Great selling and struggling from Tamura. This half of the match is all about Barnett either throwing Tamura and stuffing him with sick double leg takedowns. Tamura did a great job finding ways to grab a double wrist lock coming out of waist locks. Barnett was not just about throws too, he was using the takedowns to set up holds like toeholds and chokes. There were some great round kick battles as well. Barnett dumps Tamura on his head with Human Capture Suplex. It looks like Barnett’s size and technique would win but Tamura’s guile and quickness comes back and he gets the flash cross arm breaker for win. 

Terrific match! Instant classic! It was style that was almost dead at this point but this was killer. Really loved everything after the Tamura knee to the head! I love shoot-style

WWE World Heavyweight Champion Brock Lesnar vs John Cena vs Seth Rollins 

 Royal Rumble 2015

I was there live for this bad boy with my brother in Philly. I remember there’s a blizzard on Friday in Boston but we braved the elements driving down to see two of all-time favorites: Brock and Cena kick some ass in their prime. I have never watched the match back until now ten years later. Does it hold up or should I have left the memories alone?

Hell Yeah it holds up brutha! Probably the best Triple Threat of all time! Each wrestler stays true to their unique character. Brock Lesnar is the Horror Movie Monster. The Creature from the Black Lagoon, always stalking, always rising. John Cena is the valiant hero trying to slay the Beast by any means necessary. Seth Rollins is the coward using sneak attacks to insert himself. It is awesome.

The reason why the match works isn’t because they changed the formula it is because of the characters. Yes they work at a break-neck pace and everything feels hot. It is still a spot fest just a very well-done one. It is the characters that enhance the viewing experience and take this from Eye candy to emotionally stirring.

Brock Lesnar had a fucking Bitchin’ 2015! He starts off ROARING! The Horror Movie Monster is getting the babyface shine and the Philly crowd is loving it. Cena is still very much disliked and Rollins has some ROH street cred bur his cowardly character keep the fans from being full-throated in their support.

Brock is Unstoppable just trucking Rollins and throwing Cena around. The high spot of this segment is CHUCKING Noble & Mercury like they were nothing. I like the first big chink on the armor. Brock applies the Kimura. Cena being the valiant hero that he is Bob Backlund his way out. However Seth Rollins LEAPS onto the Pile with a knee bowling everyone over. That is the perfect microcosm of the match. 

Cena snaps off an FU on a weakened Lesnar but Rollins that little  fucking sneak throws Cena out and only gets a one. Perfect character work. 

Through some outside work, Cena and Rollins end up alone. Cena works through his finish stretch. Another reasons the match works well is that it feels like one long finish stretch from beginning to end. When Cena goes for the Five Knuckle Shuffle we get the first of the Horror Movie Monster popping up from behind and demolishing someone with a suplex. 

The next big high spot and the one burned in my memory because out seats were looking over the bottom right turnbuckle (hard cam perspective) was Brock plucking Rollins out of the air into a F-5. Saying I was able to see Brock Lesnar live multiple times in my life is a blessing.

Another thing that worked well in this Triple Threat was the use of saves to protect the finishers. Very expertly timed.

It is time slay the Beast or so we think. Three FUs and a Curb Stomp. Brock is loopy. CENA TACKLES BROCK THROUGH THE BARRICADE! SICK! Brock keeps getting up. Cena throws him into steps and Rollins DRIVES AN ELBOW THROUGH THE HEART OF TYE BEAT FROM THE TOP ROPE THROUGH THE ANNOUNCER TABLE! KILLER!

So what stops this from being a 5 star classic is the Cena/Rollins solo stretch. It is very standard 21st Century main event wrestling. My turn, your turn big bombs. It wasn’t bad but it took something unique and made it feel ordinary. Liked the use of Mercury and Noble. Cena having to expend energy neutralizing them with a stacked FU gives Rollins the time make a serious push for victory. Busting out the Phoenix Splash here was genius. GOD could Lesnar’s timing be any better. One of the best Horror Movie Monster pop up and decimations. It was electric. I liked sneaking in the one hope spot of Rollins using the MITB Case stomp but Brock plucks him again for the F5 win. From Brock return to the F5 was maybe two minutes but absolutely electric 2 minutes. 

Maybe the best 21st Century-style match ever. I want emphasize the word STYLE. Plenty of matches in 21st Century are better but they are 20th Century style matches. This kicked some serious ass. Bravo to each man playing their character to perfection.

NXT Women’s Champion Sasha Banks vs Bayley - NXT Takeover 8/22/15

What a fucking moment! It is funny watching this ten years later when ice I am fucking cold on Bayley and Mercedes has only clicked again for me recently but man as soon as the video package rolled, I was transported back in time and fuck I got a little misty when Bayley came out with the polka dots. It was definitely Dusty in the room just now. 

Bayley was tailor made for a SuperIndy. I am not surprised the character didnt translate on the main roster but who gives a fuck. It worked like gangbusters here and it is crowning glory of her work as a character. The characters are so well-established, so relatable and so well-done by each woman that it is fucking money. 

To me Bayley has the way tougher job. Anybody can be an asshole. In the hands of a lesser character actor, the Bayley character would be lame and cringing. Bayley commits to the bit and the match and the world are all better for it.

Let’s just get this out the way early, the beginning of the match is the weakest part of the match. Bayley is not a great athlete or an offensive dynamo which is fine some of the best wrestlers ever are unathletic. This shine definitely leaves a something to be desired. It’s a short shine and the match is a classic but it is the one ding. 

Bayley uses a Lucha style arm drag to discombobulate Sasha but Sasha uses her own momentum to get out the Ring and created a timeout. The genius here is that boundary conditions are a heel’s paradise. You’re setting yourself up for success for a meaningful transition here. 

Sasha goes for the double knees way too early. Bayley to her credit cuts her off but in the tumult in the corner in a boundary condition where the heels feast Sasha is able to knock Bayley off the top careening to the floor. BANG excellent transition.

Another genius element of this match is how they split the heat segment in two. The first part is more about the character work of Sasha. Being that dick heel bitch to the loveable underdog Bayley. Mocking the Wacky Arm Inflatable Tube Man to deliver a WICKED SMACK was awesome! The Top Rope Double Knees actually doesn’t look as good as the Middle Rope but I understand what they were going off given the setting and circumstances. It paid off Sasha finally hitting her signature. Then she just lays a verbal beat down that would make Mark Henry proud. Bayley Cant take anymore and gives her a STIFF kick to the mush. Brilliant. 

Whats even more Brilliant and what takes this match from Great to Classic status is that Sasha immediately cuts Bayley off with the hand psychology. They could have let Bayley run roughshod and do a full-blown comeback but they went right back to heat which was genius. They did it on the outside. They had Sasha tear off American Dream Polka Dot wrist band and just crush that hand with the steps. It was brilliant work. 

I love the escalation the first half of the match is establishing the characters and because both characters are so over and the crowd is so invested it is such an easy watch. At the same time that’s a lot of faith in Sasha and Bayley to deliver on character work. 

Thats Whats missing in today’s wrestling which is crazy because this is only ten years apart. No one takes time to establish the character; it is just Bing Bang Boom nowadays. It is because establishing the characters is scary. Silence is scary. If you just run through a bunch of moves and never take a rest you’ll never be able to hear the silence. It is an insecurity problem. You gotta believe in yourself that you can get your gimmick over and become comfortable with the uncomfortable. 

The hand psychology is when the plot of the match kicks in. They go from a character-driven match to a plot-driven match. I was a little cool on this match when it first happened. I thought it was great but not a classic. Watching it back in it is the incorporation of both these driving forces that makes this a classic. 

One thing about Sasha even though she is a heel he is a risk taker. She can’t help herself. She’s just got too much Eddie in her. She does the Rey MYSTERIO Summerslam 2002 you can argue whether or not a heel should successfully execute that spot BUT it works because just like when LeBron makes his his first three (you know the feeling LeBron fans you just hope the rest aren’t laser beam bricks) Sash is feeling it. So she goes for another one. This time Bayley knocks her off the springboard and now we have the leveling the playing field spot. 

There are really strong parts of the finishing stretch, Sasha’s stomping on the injured hand is iconic, the first  Bayley 2 Belly and ultimate win. There’s the bad 21st Century excesses of the reversed Bank Statement and the DragonRana and the ugly Bayley nearly pile driving herself on top rope flip. Overall it does leave you fist-pumping. Even if I wish they reined it in a bit more. I get it too. This was the first time the women were billed as co-main event so they wanted the DragonRana to show they were on the level of the Men. To give that crowd a little extra something something because this was their WrestleMania. I’d argue you didn’t need to do that but I also concede that I get where they are coming from.

Four Horsewoman Curtain Call I would have been against especially Sasha coming out to join and hug them. This was not a babyface vs babyface match. Sasha was a real asshole and she should be a sore loser. It was a very post-modern finish. I also understand how significant the match was and how they knew it would be instantly significant so I see that side as Well. 

I think Sasha vs Becky is the better match but that match just showed the women could do it. This match proved they were main event. Even at the time many said that this should main event over Owen’s/Balor and it should have. There was still a little doubt. This effaced all doubt. The women were just as good and just as over as the men. It is not a perfect match BUT if it was somebody’s favorite match I wouldn’t bay any eye. It is such a meaningful, significant FEEL-GOOD match man thats what pro wrestling is missing FEEL-GOOD matches. Meaningful to women’s wrestling, these two women’s career but also to NXT and the Culture at the time. It was the climax of a specific time and place and it fucking hits and it hits hard. 

Brock Lesnar vs The Undertaker - Summerslam 2015

This far surpassed my recollection of this match as I have it on par with the Roman WrestleMania match from the year. Holy fuck, Brock Lesnar is a phenomenal wrestler. I am really interested in seeing how this compares to their 2015 Hell In A Cell. I might have to rewatch their 2002 Hell In A Cell to see what is the best match they have together. 

Big Fight Feel is an understatement. I hate to harp on this point, but ten years later I am struggling to think of a match that felt like this match. This was a true blue heavyweight bout, who is the biggest dog in the yard. It is not an overly choreographed dance routine they are stand and bang and throwing bombs.

Brock Lesnar is the best at setting that tone. The way he bumrushes Takes and he forces Taker to fight through that offense and dump him. That was a fist-pumping shine. The haymakers they were throwing early were great. Brock wrestles him to the ground and Taker just NAILS him with these VICIOUS straight rights on the ground. That shit started them at 5 stars, fuck we need more of that in wrestling pronto. I liked each teasing their finisher because these are heavyweights that dont get paid by the hour. They want the KO victory immediately. Just when it looked like Taker was going to run away with it, Brock dumps with the first suplex (belly to bell) coming out of the corner. The issue with Suplex City was less the multitude in my opinion but the way it was sold. Here I do think it was oversold, but it was a way for Brock to stem the bleeding. It is established as Brock's Ace in the Hole, even if Taker is pouring it on, all it takes is one suplex to turn the tide. In later matches, it was just a way to get a cheap pop. 

I liked after the second suplex, Brock gets cocky with "Suplex City Bitch" and Takes is able to dive into a turnbuckle to knock Brock for a loop and then hit some standard Taker offense (Snake Eyes, Big Boot, Leg drop across the apron) all the while Brock has a nice steady, stream of blook trickling down his face for the remainder of the match. I am not a vampire, but that is the perfect amount of blood for this moment. I loved the counter to Chokeslam. It was the perfect time for Taker to go for the chokeslam, but the way Brock did mid-air and with force was so credible and then BANG~! Suplex. Just like that Brock has that puncher's chance to totally turn a match on a dime because of his raw power and strength. 

The F-5 on the table was a sick spot and ensured the 21st Century crowd would be on their side because they are also delivering highspots. We get a little Cinematic here as Taker rolls back in at a count of 9, but it is good shit. Brock says "Ill Kill You" and Taker says "Youll have to" as he gozzles Brock from his knees and delivers an emphatic Chokeslam. It is always a case by case basis and this one worked. It set up the great Tombstone. 

Now we get to iconic part of the match as Brock sits up after the Tombstone first laughing and Taker does his Zombie Situp and mocks him back with laughter then trade heavy bombs. It was fucking sick! Again it is a case by case basis with a different twosome this could be lame and cringe-inducing but here it is just BADASS!

Brock gets the Kimura in the corner, but Taker counters with Last Ride. This is when the match goes from ***** OMG to MOTYC. Without much transition, Brock gets two F-5s and kick outs. The epic selling starts to take hold and it feels more my turn, your turn as Taker gets Hell's Gate. No real transition between Last Ride and F-5s or the F-5s and Hells Gate hurt the stretch. The counter into the Kimura is also pretty flimsy.

I actually kinda liked the finish upon replay. Taker taps in the view of the timekeeper but not the ref because Lil Naitch is watching Brock's shoulders on the Kimura and Brock is really wriggling to keep his shoulders off the mat. This is the beauty of pro wrestling is the added dimension of the pin that MMA does not have. By forcing the ref to watch the shoulders and Brock to keep his shoulders off the mat, it opens up this dimension as well as making submission holds like the Kimura and Hells Gate and Triangle Choke disadvantageous in pro wrestling. Heyman jumps for joy and into the ring that Brock has one-upped his Mania victory by making Taker tap. Lil Naitch is indignant that the Timekeeper went rogue calling for the bell on his own. Lil Naitch says the match is not over. Taker gives Brock a ballshot! Hells Gate! Brock gives him the Finger and passes out to give Taker the win by TKO. 

Fantastic Heavyweight Slugfest! Just two big uglies throwing haymakers and dropping each other on their heads. Like I said I didnt hate the finish as you needed a little sumthin sumthin to set up the third match because you knew Taker had to go over here to avenge his loss at Mania. If was really the section between Dueling Sit-Ups and the finish that dropped the match from a Top 100 Candidate to just one of the best matches of 2010s. Definitely check it out.

Four & Three Quarters Star Matches

IWGP Heavyweight Champion Keiji Mutoh vs Hiroyoshi Tenzan - NJPW 6/14/95

Leave it to Hirata to make Tenzan look like Stone Cold in terms of charisma. This is in the Budokan, typically the domain of All Japan. Tenzan is tag team champion and Chono is out with him.

Woke up in the middle of the night in the Azores and call me crazy but this is FUCKING AWESOME! 

Even though Mutoh looks a little taller and wider than Tenzan, they stick to script that Tenzan is big bruising goon and Mutoh needs to use speed.

The match works so well because Tenzan gives Mutoh fucking NOTHING at the beginning of the match. He is this torrential force of nature. He has the Champion reeling and wrestling off his back foot. This is basically Tenzan’s rookie year on the main roster so to speak and he is showing great poise. He felt like a bull in a China shop but in a different way than Stab Hansen. Hansen is frenetic and chaotic. Tenzan is straight ahead smash mouth. Mutoh was throwing desperation kicks just to get a moment of respite from Tenzan’s suffocating offense. Mutoh would clamp down on a hold after the kick but Tenzan would keep coming. I loved Mutoh’s response to a loss In a shoulder block battle to apply drop toehold but Tenzan kept coming. When Tenzan went for a cross arm breaker it looked like Mutoh was going to wake up lest he be steamrolled. We get the Mutoh Elbow but when Mutoh went for a single leg crab Tenzan was having none of it and just fucking stuffed his attempt. That’s when I knew I watching something special. Nothing was given everything was earned. 

Tenzan Ramps it up here and honestly it looked like it was going to a blow out. Mongolian Chops. Headbutt rain down from the sky. We were one Tenzansault from a shocking upset. Mutoh hits a Dropkick to Tenzan’s ass who brains himself on the top of the Ring post and takes a nasty tumble to the floor. It is official this match is fucking great. Mutoh Bulldog on the floor. Mutoh has wounded the bull and needs to finish him off. Spring board Dropkick. Mutoh goes for a moonsault. TENZAN ELECTRIC CHAIR DROP! The Symmetry! The Hook! The hook is who can hit the Moonsault first. This is Marty Sleeze fucking wrestling here. They are throwing bombs trying to get this moonsault. Tenzan eats nothing but canvas. Mutoh tries his backbreaker moonsault combo twice comes up empty both times. Then the match gets even better! Tenzan in the pursuit of giving Mutoh absolutely fucking nothing plucks Mutoh out of his customary back handspring and MANHANDLES him tossing him into the floor. It is a gnarly bump. Fucking Mutoh is PISSED! He comes in fists balled and cocked. He UNLOADS on Tenzan until he bleeds! I wanted blood on the Ring post shot and we got here. Mutoh rips up the protective mat and bulldogs Tenzan on the exposed concrete. If you didn’t know already this match FUCKING RULES! Mutoh back inside working the cut with punches when Tenzan let’s out a PRIMAL ROAR! OMFG LETS FUCKING GO! Tenzan spinning wheel kick wipes out Mutoh. Tenzan FINALLY HITS THE MOONSAULT 1-2-NO! YES! Tenzan undeterred goes for his Top Rope Headbutt but no one is home and he eats a face full canvas. As you can expect it is off the to the races for Mutoh who uses his Springboard Dropkick, Top Rope Frankensteiner , backbreaker and Moonsault to finish off the very game Tenzan as a challenger. This exceeded all expectations and was the best IWGP Title Match of 1995! Fuck it! This rocked so damn hard!

Keiji Mutoh & Taiyo Kea vs Toshiaki Kawada & Mitsuya Nagai - AJPW 12/7/01 RWTL Finals

THIS FUCKING RULED! 

Keiji Mutoh super push is still going full bore. He main evented every All Japan Budokan show in 2001. He has been the Triple Crown Champion since June and won the Tag Team Titles with Kea in October from Tenryu & Anjoh. Now here he is in Real World Tag League Final with Kea in the last Budokan main event of the year. I definitely think Mutoh earned the push both in terms of box office and quality matches as his 2001 is one of the best calendar years any wrestler has ever produced. It was not just his reinvention but Post-Split All Japan was the perfect platform for the reinvention. Inoki really started pushing the shooters hard in April of 2001 with Fujita winning IWGP title and NOAH was just a continuation of 90s All Japan. Mutoh did not fit any scene. In the 90s he always played second fiddle to Hashimoto. Post-Split All Japan have him the perfect place to finally play a leading role and with main event level opponents in Kawada and Tenryu he knocked it out of the park. It was a perfect symbiotic relationship. All Japan needed him just as bad as he needed them. 

Due to some urgent needs at work, was not able to immediately review this match after watching it so going back and watching for a second time because this match is so badass and I want to make sure I capture every badass detail. 

Mutoh sure loved going to the Early Shining Wizard well a lot in 2001, but man outside that Chono match, it works so well. Kawada drills him with a Back Drop Driver. SHINING WIZARD~! BANG~! Mutoh is head rocked so he tags in Kea. Kea does not do anything super crazy, but he throws a nice kick. Nagai bails Kawada out enough that Kawada hits his famous kick and then a GREAT LEG SWEEP~! Kea is good at one thing and thats throwing round kicks so him and Nagai are peanut butter jelly throwing kicks. Nagai BURIES a knee in the breadbasket and Nagai is on fire. Mutoh tries to help out but eats a knee of his own. Nagai has Kea reeling with all the kicks. Kea hits a dropkick to stymie Nagai long enough to tag out which is wise. 

Mutoh immediately dropkicks the knee. The Boo Birds are out for that. I LOVE how Nagai tries to fight through the ONSLAUGHT of Dropkicks to the Knee but eventually succumbs to a series of Dragon Leg Screws. He successfully wards off a Figure-4 with kicks to the head. I love how Nagai was fighting for his life. Each dropkick, Dragon Leg Screw he made it seem so important that he keep fighting and culminated in great struggle over the Figure-4. Like Kea, he wisely tagged out to Kawada. 

Kawada and Mutoh have this badass exchange. That just feels like two Aces vying for supremacy. Classic Kawada Kicks. Mutoh throws a potato. Mutoh Kappou Kick! Back Handspring Elbow. Bulldog. SHINING WIZARD BLOCK~! KAWADA LARIAT! Every move in this match feels existential. Mutoh BLOCKS Enziguiri. DROPKICK TO THE KNEE! BOOS! Kawada gets the enziguiri on the Dragon Leg Screw attempt. NAGAI KICKS THE HAMMIES AND DRAGON LEG SCREWS MUTOH! I LOVE WHEN OPPONENTS THROW MUTOH'S OFFENSE BACK AT HIM! This match is MARK OUT CITY! These are great Dragon Leg Screws!

MUTOH DRAGON LEG SCREWS NAGAI! He gets the Figure-4 with Kea playing guard dog. Drama off the charts! Mutoh dropkicks the knee of the fallen Nagai after the rope break to big boos. Kea has some impressive high spots like the Vaderbomb and Superfly Splash. He is just missing that IT factor. He is a fine wrestler, but he just doesnt have IT. It does not drag this particular match down, but he is clearly #4 in there. 

Springboard dropkick by Mutoh! Backbreaker -> Moonsault! 1-2-Kawada Saves! Kawada High Kick! Mutoh is OUT~! Kawada Kneedrop. Top Rope Nagai Flying Knee! 1-2-NO! Kawada Yakuza Kick! Mutoh BLASTS Nagai with an Elbow...Dragon Leg Screw on Kawada. Dont be bringing that in my house! Kea dropkicks Nagai's knees to boos. This is the most heel heat I have heard from a Japanese crowd. TKO but Kawada saves. Nagai desperation German on Nagai. Kawada is in the wrong fucking corner because this match is so chaotic I love it. Kawada is reaching out for the tag and Nagai is desperate for it. BANG~! SHINING WIZARD~! GOD BLESS THESE FOUR! Kea German 1-2-NO! Kawada saves on the TKO attempt.

Here comes the best part of the match. Mutoh and Kea like a pack of hyenas just nonstop dropkick Kawada's knees. It is so fucking awesome! Kawada's selling is so fucking good! Crowd booing so heavily! Mutoh doing his Pro Wrestling Love pose to boos is incredible! DOUBLE SHINING WIZARD~! THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN THE FINISH! I would have gone 5 if it was GODDAMN! TKO! 1-2-3! THIS MATCH FUCKING RULES!

I watched this twice! Totally holds up! This is fucking awesome! 

NXT Women's Champion Sasha Banks vs Becky Lynch - NXT Takeover 5/20/15

Almost ten years to the day it happened, I am rewatching this. I remember watching this ten years ago and being blown away. It was the day I adopted Becky as my favorite Horsewomen. I remember traveling all over New England in 2016-17 watching her and my boy, AJ wrestle on Smackdown. It is still my belief that this is the best women’s match in North American history (I will continue to revisit that claim in the next decade). 

What may be most impressive about this match is the context of which I watched it in. I am disillusioned with 2025 pro wrestling. Until the Harley Cameron feud, I was really down on Sasha/Mercedes this past year. And as much as I did like Becky/Lyra, but Becky’s character has grown long in the tooth. Coming off Robinson vs Inoki 1975 last night, there was a part of me that though would the match still hold up. Would it feel too 21st Century?

I am here to emphatically declare WHO AM I TO DOUBT BECKY LYNCH AND SASHA BANKS BABY!

This match rules no matter the context or mood! The easiest comp is Ohtani versus Samurai from January 1996 with the dueling limb psychology and the attention to detail. This match is wrestled like high-end, mat-based juniors wrestling. Look how much time they spend in contact with each other. They are wrestling, struggling for position. It is NOT a track meet. NOT a gymnastics routine. It is a fucking pro wrestling match. God bless them.

I remember immediately why I was instantly enamored with this match: Becky came out firing. Using a drop-down into a trip! Ankle pick out of a cross cross! I would say this if they were men so I’ll say it here, that shit gives me a pro wrestling boner! Wrinkles to an otherwise ordinary exchange and then consolidating the advantage with a hold or pinning combination. I remember being lucky enough to go live to see Becky vs Belair at RAW in Providence in 2021 if memory serves me right Becky busted out similar moves that night :)

Becky was targeting the arm but Sasha was really judicious here. She didn’t oversell anything. Becky had a strategy but Sasha kept her cool. I love the use of the apron to give the heel an advantage. Becky was overwhelming the Champ early with the full court press but Sasha catching the kick and wrenching Becky down by the wrist shoulder first onto apron was a killer transition. They sold it in such a way that it felt consequential.

Aaaaahhh the days when Sasha would mock and taunt her opponents. Becky debuted her steampunk look that night as Corey Graves makes sure to capture for posterity with all his snide remarks.

Sasha works the arm really well. The Double Knees to the bad arm is the crown Jewel and gives Otani/Sammy vibes! Short Arm Scissors is a favorite of mine and we get the Backlund hulk up from Becky. My favorite paying homage to another favorite. 

I love how Sasha uses a Lucha style arm drag to discombobulate Becky but also put her in position for the Double Knees!

Becky does a good job as a one arm woman making her comeback firing back. She is able to pull Sasha shoulder first into the post to give her big opportunity to torture Sasha and set her up for he patented Disarm-Her. The torture of using her feet to hyperextend her elbow sealed the deal as one of the best Becky offensive performances of her career. I love the use of a blocked vertical suplex into a takedown leading to the Disarm-Her near fall.

Sasha does a nice suicide dive to the floor but Becky kinda sorta catches her and once she recovers it is not clear where she wants to deposit her and it led to Becky kinda slamming her against the steps. It was one weak spot. It was made even weirder because they pretty much go into the finish immediately after with Sasha winning with the Bank Statement.

Absolutely terrific pro wrestling. Duel limb psychology. Minimalist. Ground-based. Body on body. Everything was consequential. Efficient at ~15 minutes. It was Becky’s coming out party solidifying her as a Four Horsewomen. For Sasha it began discussions of her being the American Female GOAT. For American Women’s Wrestling, this is the match was the turning point when all the sliding scales were thrown out and women proved they were every bit as good as the men sometimes better! Still my pick for best US women’s wrestling match of all time! We will see if it changes as I watch the last decade over again. 

Five Star Match

NWF Heavyweight Champion Antonio Inoki vs Billy Robinson - NJPW 12/11/75 2/3 Falls

Greatest Match Ever voting is on June 30th at https://gweproject.freeforums.net/ and I am in hotel room in Minnesota (taking a class at the University, Go Gophers!) and I figured it has been a long time since I have had some time to sit down and watch an hour long match. Lets watch one of my favorites Antonio Inoki go up against somebody have not seen nearly enough of, Billy Robinson. This match is coming up on its 50 year anniversary. 

First Fall: I can see why a lot of people who dont usually like Inoki like this as Inoki is far more "subdued" for lack of a better term. Robinson is really in charge and takes the meat of the first 20 minutes. As someone who likes Inoki it was a bit jarring to watch his opponent take so much of the match, but variety is the spice of life. Robinson wins the majority of the early exchanges: headlock, armdrag takedown, a brilliant gutwrench out of an Inoki facelock. Inoki works a long, tight cravat. There's a nice full nelson exchange which ends with an Inoki mule kick so Inoki is starting to win. Things get chippy when Inoki has Robinson's legs tied up and he keeps swiping the arm out from Robinson as he is trying to hold himself up. Robinson gets frustrated and breaks free and gives Inoki a stiff slap. Next thing you know they both take a massive tumble over the top to the floor courtesy of a Robinson belly to belly suplex. I like how tempers flared and Robinson's instinct was just to chuck Inoki over the top rope, his own well-being be damned. Back in Robinson wants a butterfly suplex, but Inoki blocks and he settles for a cross-armbreaker. The work on the cross-armbreaker is exquisite. The pop for Inoki countering into an Indian Deathlock is huge! They end up in the ropes. Robinson gets a Robinson Backbreaker out of an Inoki headlock which was sick. People bit on that nearfall as did given this 2/3 falls. Greta Inoki sell. Robinson Boston Crab. The drama is high! Great Inoki sell of how hard it was to reverse. Inoki attempts his own but settles for a leg lace as 20 minutes elapses. Started slow, but picked up in a big way once tempers started to flare. 

Love that at the 20 minute mark Inoki is trying to put on a Boston Crab and at the 40 minute mark he finally applies it. What a tremendous 20 minutes of grappling. The struggle is real. Coming out of the leg lace at 20 minute mark, Robinson has to work hard to break free and goes into the bodyscissors, but that leaves him open to one of my all-time favorite counters: The Ankle Cross, 20 years before Volk Han baby! I was pop pop POPPING here in Minnesota 50 years later. Then they out do themselves by working the best damn headscissors I have ever seen in my life. It was so damn good I had to take 10 second video clip send it to my wife with the caption "What happened to the game I loved" because this shit is the shit, whereas as the shit today is the shits. I will not do the struggle justice. Watch the struggle not just to escape the hold by Robinson but the struggle of Inoki to maintain the hold. That's pro wrestling, baby. I love that Robinson's first instinct out the headscissors is to get a pinfall and second is to stretch the neck. The crowd popped when he finally got out of the headscissors. Thats pro wrestling, baby. They trade dropkicks and Inoki's looked fucking great. There were so many Butterfly Suplex attempts. Tokyo and me are ready to lose our shit when someone finally snaps off a Butterfly. Best Damn Reverse Neckbreaker youll ever see in your life by Robinson here coming out of the Cravat. Really nifty Tombstone Piledriver that feels so organic the way he falls forward but is too close to the ropes for a pin. Theres an Inoki abdominal stretch somewhere in this stretch that gets over as a nearfall because it is Inoki. They battle over a bodyslam that turns into a Full Nelson by Robinson, but Inoki pulls the stump and applies Boston Crab. This is how pro wrestling should be. 40 minutes in and still no fall. 

Inoki falls in love with the Boston Crab to his detriment. Robinson breaks free but Inoki still wants it. Robinson takes a hard Whip to the buckles and sells it like a million bucks. Inoki sees blood and wants to finish weakened Robinson with the Boston Crab, but Robinson musters up all his strength stands on his head, twists and sends Inoki flying. Watch the time they take to set this up and really milk the struggle. Robinson scrambles for a backslide 1-2-3! Just like that around 43 minute mark he goes up 1-0! What a fall!

Second Fall: Unless, we have 100% proof that something is a shoot, my default position is that it is a work. I can see how this fall feels like a shoot with how uncooperative Robinson is being with his stalling and you do get the feeling from Inoki's disposition that he seems anxious he might get the tying fall in time leading to some serious egg on his face, but at the same time I think that's just really good selling on their part. Typically the second fall is a very short fall in these type of matches (<5 minutes) and the drama is in if someone can break the time and goes the full 60. I actually liked this a lot more. I kinda figured it would go 1-1, BUT given how long it was taking to get there, I started to worry. As an Inoki fan, I was concerned and it was egging me on. I was feeling emotionally moved. Maybe Robinson went off script, but I dont think so. I think the fan was to put the heat on could Inoki tie it. Then everyone knows it was going 60. If Inoki tied it with ten minutes to go, yes there would still be heat, but not as much as Inoki tying it with a minute left on the clock. 

The fall was very interesting. Robinson opened with a backslide the move that gained him the first fall, which I liked. Inoki BLASTED him with a hard back elbow that sent him careening over the top rope to the floor. Robinson sells it like his bell is rung. Inoki gets two easy suplexes: vertical and belly to back as he looks like he is going to cruise to a tie. Then a curious thing happens Robinson in his stupor keeps falling into the ropes. Is he selling having his bell rung? Is he parking the bus? Taking that 1-0 lead to the time limit and claim the World Title? Is he shooting and making Inoki sweat? That's the magic of pro wrestling. Regardless of the actual motivations and it is uber compelling television. Inoki goes for the Argentine Backbreaker and they get into a tremendous tussle over a backslide. Robinson pops off the Butterfly Suplex for two. He has stopped selling having his bell rung and it becomes apparent that he is stalling on purpose to try to milk the clock for victory. Inoki and the crowd are pissed! There is a great Robinson German Suplex that you think might even seal the deal 2-zip. He is getting under Inoki's skin and exploiting it. In an insane feat of strength like 55 minutes in, Inoki bridge with Robinson's full weight on him with no hands and then Robinson slams his body weight onto Inoki twice and Inoki holds like the muthafuckin man. What a stud. Inoki really starts firing up and smacking Robinson around trying to goad him into fighting. Excellent finish stretch. Inoki Dropkick. Pin. No. Baba-esque chop. Pin. No. Finally the Butterfly! Pin. No. Bodyslam! Pin. No. Robinson comes back with European Uppercuts and a Butterfly Suplex of his own! Holy shit! It is coming down to the wire. Robinson misses on a chop. OCTOPUS STRETCH! ROBINSON GIVES! CROWD GOES APESHIT! 50 YEARS LATER IN MINNESOTA I LOST MY MIND!

Third Fall: THREE INOKI DROPKICKS! MISSED THE FOURTH! Robinson 1-2-NO! THEY ARE THROWING ELBOWS! IT IS A STREET FIGHT! TIME EXPIRES!

Damn what a great match. This is pitch perfect sporting pro wrestling. I love narrative-based wrestling, but this is one of the best matches I have seen where pro wrestling models sport. They are both always looking for the win and always looking for the advantage. Robinson's stalling down the stretch and making me believe that he might fuck Inoki over seals the deal for me. ***** one of the top 100 best matches of all time. 








 

Tuesday, March 31, 2020

Pro Wrestling Love vol. 51: The Best of WWE 2005-2009 (John Cena, Batista, Randy Orton, Shawn Michaels)

Hey Yo Stud Muffins & Foxy Ladies,

Pro Wrestling Love vol. 51:
The Best of World Wrestling Entertainment 2005-2009

Objective:  Break up the Greatest Match Ever Project (hosted at http://gweproject.freeforums.net/) into more manageable chunks to help me build my Top 100 List for the project.

Motivation: Contribute to the discussion around these matches to enrich my own understanding of pro wrestling and give a fresh perspective for old matches and even hopefully discover great pro wrestling matches that have been hidden by the sands of time.

Subject: This fifty-first volume of Pro Wrestling Love is the beginning of the Top 12 countdown of the best matches to take place in WWE between 2005-2009. The year 2005 saw John Cena & Batista win the World Championships at Wrestlemania heralding the beginning of a new era. Even though stylistically there would be a lot of aesthetic holdovers from the Attitude Era, in terms of new main eventers Cena, Batista along with Randy Orton and Edge were the vanguard of a new truly 21st century generation. However, they were supported by Attitude Era stars Shawn Michaels, HHH, The Undertaker, Kurt Angle (until 2006) and Chris Jericho. The reason I chose 2009 as an ending year is because 2010 WWE lost a lot of this previously mentioned support structure. The year 2010 saw Shawn Michaels go into retirement, HHH & Undertaker went into semi-retirement, Jericho left and it was Edge's last full year. The year 2010 saw a complete overhaul in the WWE main event scene.  You can revisit past Pro Wrestling Love Volumes at ridingspacemountain.blogspot.com. You can check out the full version of these reviews in ProWrestlingOnly.com by going to the forums and finding the folders associated with the date of the match.

Contact Info: @superstarsleeze on Twitter, Instagram & ProWrestlingOnly.com.


Honorable Mentions

WWE Women's Champion Trish Stratus vs Mickie James - WrestleMania XXII
Beth Phoenix vs Melina - WWE One Night Stand 2008 I Quit Match
WWE Women's Champion Beth Phoenix vs Candice Michelle - WWE No Mercy 2008

A trio of great divas matches from this era proving that great women's wrestling in the USA existed before 2014. I highly recommended Beth Phoenix vs Melina I Quit Match which I included in my Top 100 Greatest WWE Matches of All Time as a personal fun pick to spruce up the bottom part of my list. It is a truly excellent match and it is Beth Phoenix playing human pretzel-maker with the ultra-supple Melina.

Ric Flair vs Shawn Michaels - WrestleMania XXIV
Shawn Michaels vs Chris Jericho - Judgment Day 2008
Shawn Michaels vs Batista - One Night Stand 2008 Stretcher Match
World Heavyweight Champion Chris Jericho vs Shawn Michaels - No Mercy 2008

It is truly amazing at his age that Ric Flair has such a great retirement match. This not just nostalgia talking that is a legitimately great match. It also spawned Shawn Michaels' third career year. Most people live for one career year, but Shawn has had three: 1986, 1997 and 2008. Of course was incredible is that each year is in three different decades and also three different roles. In 1986 he was pretty boy babyface in the Rockers vs Rose & Somers, in 1997 he was a King Prick heel in D-X and in 2008 he was the elder statesman having the last great blood feud in WWE history with Chris Jericho and an underrated feud with Batista that spun off of the Ric Flair match. Every Shawn Michaels perfromance from WrestleMania XXIV to No Mercy 2008 (including the Summerslam angle) needs to be watched to full appreciate the greatness of this run.

John Morrison vs Evan Bourne - WWECW 4/14/09
World Heavyweight Champion CM Punk vs John Morrison - Smackdown 6/26/09
WWE Intercontinental Champion Rey Mysterio vs John Morrison - Smackdown 9/4/09

The biggest revelation of going back and re-watching all this WWE wrestling from 2005-2009 is that John Morrison is a fucking great wrestler. If he could cut a halfway decent promo, he would be a megastar. I thought he would be abother Kofi-lite wrestler, but the dude kicks ass and has great escalation and psychology. There are probably a ton of John Morrison hidden gems waiting to be uncovered.

World Heavyweight Champion Batista vs Triple H - WWE Vengeance 2005 Hell In A Cell
WWE Intercontinental Champion Ric Flair vs Triple H - WWE Taboo Tuesday 2005 Steel Cage
Triple H vs Umaga - Cyber Sunday 2007 Street Fight
World Tag Team Champions Rated RKO vs D-Generation X - New Year's Revolution 2007

Depending who you are, you either are totally surprised that Triple H did not have a match that made my top 12 or that just makes total sense. The Game was not without great performances as the four match above can attest to, but he did not have anything was truly classic. The best match of the bunch was the Batista Hell In A Cell match, BUT if you want a hidden gem that no one talks about check out the Umaga brawl from Cyber Sunday 2007 it is randomly great.

ECW Champion Jack Swagger vs Christian - WWECW 2/24/09

Ahhhh yes, the match that got so much hype that we all thought Jack Swagger was the next big thing in pro wrestling. Well 11 years later, maybe he can make something of this Moxley program in AEW (lets see how that sentence ages). This match ages really well. One of the greatest cat & mouse matches you will ever see. Swagger looks like a killer and Christian looks like the wrestling genius that so many claim he is.

Eddie Guerrero vs Rey Mysterio - WWE Judgement Day 2005
Eddie Guerrero vs Rey Mysterio - Great American Bash 2005
The feud where the uber-popular, wickedly charismatic Eddie Guerrero was desperately determined to get him to hate him. He actually made it work. It is testament to himself and to Rey for making it happen. The "Who's Your Papi" shirt during the Dominic portion of the angle was great. Seeing Dominic all grown up this past year was so weird. Brock threw that boy around that was awesome. They had an all-time classic during this feud, but these are worth a watch.

Chris Benoit vs William Regal - Velocity 7/16/05
Simply awesome.

Hulk Hogan vs Shawn Michaels - Summerslam 2005
I always heard that Shawn treated this match as a joke, but I dont think he did at all. This was wicked fun. I loved the build to this match so much when I was a teenager in 2005. Shawn started channeling 1997 Shawn and it was awesome! This was Shawn Michaels doing a 1989 Hulk Hogan as the big bumping stooge heel. This is the match Mr. Perfect should have had with The Hulkster. The key difference was that Michaels got the offense and cheated his ass off to add to the drama. He was not just a pinball for Hogan but he through relentless cheating actually looked poised to defeat Hogan

World Heavyweight Champion Batista vs Undertaker - Wrestlemania XXIII
Hoss sprint! These two decide to do the Kentucky Derby of Mania matches and just have an awesome bomb-throwing sprint! It is famous deservedly so!

World Heavyweight Champion Kurt Angle vs Undertaker - WWE No Way Out 2006
Chris Benoit vs Finlay - Smackdown 5/5/06
Chris Benoit vs Finlay - WWE Judgement Day 2006
WWE Champion John Cena vs Edge - WWE Unforgiven TLC Match

The year 2006 was NOT represented at all on this list so I grouped all these matches together as they were the best from otherwise lean year. Originally Cena vs Edge made my Top 100 WWE Matches, but going back and watching some matches from 2007 and reviewing my reviews, I have to say it just misses the cut, but I do think that is an all-time great feel good victory for Cena against his best archrival until Punk.


The Top 12ish Best Match of WWE 2005-2009

#12. (TIE) WWE Champion Randy Orton vs Shawn Michaels - Survivor Series 2007

Greatest Randy Orton match ever? I think most would say the Catcus match from Backlash 2004, but I think this one is definitively better. Is there anything else? While I do think Orton was great in this match, it was of course really the Shawn Michaels show. Some context: as an offshoot of the D-X vs Rated RKO feud in the beginning of 2007, Orton punted HBK to give his summer school vacation. Michaels came back in October and challenged Orton for the championship at Cyber Sunday, but Orton punched him in the balls to get intentionally DQ'd. So in the rematch, if Orton gets DQ'd he loses the title, BUT Michaels cant use the Superkick. This forces Michaels to wrestle a different type of match.



There is a lot to love in the first ten minutes of this match. Michaels uses a ton of vice grips (cravat, front chancery) on the head and neck of Orton to control him and attempt to get an early pinfall. The hallmark of this was how tenacious HBK was applying these holds. Really controlling Orton and driving the knees into his head. Orton did a great job selling it all. It also shows that Michaels is going to try to win by taking it to the ground and outwrestling Orton. Orton's counter was punching him right in the face on a break in the corner. Great heel wrestling from Orton here. Then trying to goad Michaels into Superkicking him; Michaels fakes him out and chops him. Orton was really good at selling these fake out spots as Michaels knowing that as much as I love ground wrestling and tight psychology the live crowd needs something to pop them and so he hits a baseball slide and an Asai Moonsault, but the spots are really organic well set up because Orton bites so hard on the pump fakes. So many wrestlers knowing that they are going be faked out just go through the motions, but here Orton makes you believe that he believes he will be hit by the pump fake. Good stuff. Loved Orton rolling through a crossbody for two and then immediately decking him with a European uppercut. I loved the urgency there. Michaels shine ends with a Sharpshooter. Ten years since Montreal at this point. (I cant believe it has been TWENTY years as of this writing!). Crazy to think Michaels would be wrestling Bob Orton's kid for the championship ten years after the Screwjob. The Sharpshooter gets a good reaction of course. From there, Orton thumbs HBK in the eye and snaps his neck across the ropes. Great heel transition. Really good organic set up to the Hangsmans DDT. Orton has a solid punch and an amazing European Uppercut. I am starting to like him ten years after the fact. This is where the match does down a notch. First the customary Orton resthold and then the very basic Michaels comeback. The Michaels comeback requires both wrestles to go through the motions rather than feel it. Loved Orton's dropkick to stymie the comeback. Shawn's gets melodramatic after his elbow drop tuning up the band but it is a fake out to get a small package. Meh, overthinking it there. Just go for the pin. Too elaborate of a ruse. Then again I hate the whole I need to wait for my opponent to stand before I hit my big move. After this, the match gets awesome again. Michaels goes for submissions (Crossface, Anglelock) and Orton tries to punt his head off. Good stuff. The finish is awesome. Orton goes for the RKO, but Michaels pushes him off, hesitates on Superkick and that slight hesitation leads to BANG RKO~!

First half was awesome, tenacious Shawn Michaels ground wrestling and Orton playing the heel really well. Great timed spots and sound psychology. Falls a little off the rails with some overly cinematic Michaels stuff, but comes roaring back with Michaels pugnaciously going for a submission victory but falling prey to the RKO when his instincts takeover to hit Sweet Chin Music. Magnificent. ****1/2

#12. (TIE) WWE Champion John Cena vs Shawn Michaels - Wrestlemania XXIII

Once Shawn Michaels was committed to wrestling as the heel in this match, this was excellent and a top flight performance by both wrestlers. Michaels is clearly at a size and power disadvantage, but he is accustomed to that and he chooses to battle this by taking out one of Cena’s wheels. Now, Cena is never out of any match because he has a puncher’s chance. Similarly, Michaels can always fall back on Sweet Chin Music. It is Cena’s ability to avoid Sweet Chin Music that pays dividends, but when he gets hit with it the question becomes can he bounce back? The weakest part of the match is the beginning, which I thought Michaels took way too much of it. 

Michaels wants a handshake with his co-Tag Team Champion. Cena hesitates so he slaps him. Cena takes some wild swings, but Shawn ducks. Shawn punches and a big chop sends Cena reeling. Michaels is in Cena’s head and using speed. HBK is the veteran and even though Cena has been champion for 20 of the past 24 months, there is a lot of pressure to vanquish a former champion like Michaels. Michaels outwrestling Cena with headlocks and again ducks punches and punches of his own and chop. Cena is clearly frustrated. HBK looks to build some speed and finally Cena nails a big clothesline. They establish Cena’s power game is Cena’s key to victory. Big Boos for that clothesline. Michaels hiptosses Cena from ring to the floor and then Asai Moonsault. This is way too rough of a start for Cena.

HBK goes full heel here and the match kicks into a next level goes into heat segment with chops in corner and then big sledge to the straight leg., Goes to work on the leg with great selling from Cena all the usual stuff from HBK (chopblocks, ropes wrenching, kicks). Really fucking well done. Great selling by Cena and there is some really cool corner work. They spend a couple minutes just in one corner with Cena trying to battle out and Michaels trying to suffocate him. I loved the chess moves here. Cena starts landing bombs and always has a punchers chance. Big one sends Michaels tumbling back, but he bulrushes Cena back into the corner to trap him there. Cena fights back for survival. Michaels tries to drive the shoulder again, but Cena collapses to the side and Michaels head strikes the post and is bleeding. Awesome transition! Michaels is wobbly. Cena recovers and smokes him with a big clothesline. Here comes that big power Cena offense getting on top and ground n pound. Big boos. Shouldertackles. Knee is messed up. Five Knuckle shuffle. Michaels avoids FU. Michaels is now desperate and thinks the match is slipping through his fingers so he pulls the trigger on Sweet Chin Music, but nails the ref. Cena looks FU, nope, DDT. This levels playing field between the bloody HBK and exhausted Cena. 

Michaels hits a PILEDRIVER ON THE STEPS! Total Mark Out by me! No ref, here comes one running down the ramp and only a two count. Michaels does his comeback sequence now. Michaels sneering and looking mean as hell. He wants to polish Cena off with Sweet Chin Music. Massive Cena clothesline turns the tide! Big time slugfest and Cena nails the FU, but only two. He wants to up the ante with the super FU, but Michaels knocks him off top rope. Crossbody, roll through FU NO! I totally bit on that as the finish. Michaels lands on his feet and tries Sweet chin music, but Cena ducks. Now Michaels is off balance making him vulnerable for the STFU. There is an awesome struggle that leads into a HBK cradle, but a missed Enziguri finally leads into the STFU. That should have been the finish. The STFU struggle was really well-done. Yes, that is criticism #2 they long just a bit too long. Ref and Cena argue and BANG! Sweet Chin music, Michaels down and he crawls over for only a 2 count. They take an 8 count to get back up each leaning on the other for a long time. This is clearly Shawn’s flair for the dramatic shining through. Cena tries the FU, no, but applies a good-looking STFU for the win.

Excellent chess match that stayed true to both men’s character. I have no clue what was up with the beginning as it was way too much Shawn and the match did not seem to climax at the right spot. There was a lot more heat for the first STFU. The long double count late in a match is a cool idea to milk a spot, but the whole leaning against each other and then rather pedestrian final finish sequence did compare as well as the previous STFU stretch. The knee psychology was awesome and the stretch run was totally engrossing. Too many issues to be match of the year, but still an excellent match. ****1/2

#11. John Cena vs Batista - Summerslam 2008

Terrific match, exactly what I needed to see to remind me how great a big match player, John Cena is. Total Dome, Clash of the Titans style match that if it happened in the Tokyo Dome or at WrestleMania would be more fondly remembered. Honestly, I am surprised this is not more well-known. I think ever since 2005 or so there has been a problem with the WWE's myth-making machine in dubbing matches as classics. In the 90s, the WWF drilled in the fans heads which matches were the classics, but I think that has sort of subsided over the years. It is a real shame that awesome matches like these are forgotten rather than celebrated.

The beauty of this match is the parallel lives these men have led, both winning their first championships at WrestleMania XXI ushering in the modern era. Cena was the standard bearer for RAW and Batista was the face of Smackdown. They did a great job keeping them apart for three years. That was the great thing of the brand split is allowed them to create their own dream matches. Just needed to wait 3-5 years and voila fans would be pumped to see a match of this magnitude. Just watching them make their entrances felt electric. It feels like the pinnacle of this era of the WWE. I thought the match they worked was pitch perfect.

Face vs face matches work best when there is a lot of symmetry and eveness. This match had it in spades. The way they each had one slam a piece. They each had one suplex a piece. They had the same number of pin attempts. On top of that, these are two faces known for their power. You add in that Clash of Titans feel. The power game being on display. I love how this match is worked around finisher attempts. Going for a finisher is dramatic. You know the match could end. It creates a moment of chaos. If he hits it, he could win. But the possibilities are even more exciting if he doesn't. Going for a finish will freak your opponent out as he scrambles to evade it. This opens him up to be clobbered once he has wriggled free. So even though you don't hit it, you can take command of the match we see this with Batista going for the BatistaBomb early, Cena evades, but eats a clothesline. Going for a finish is also a gamble. You are committed to the move, but you don't know your opponent will react. Batista's evasion of the FU leads to him chopblocking the knee and leading to a kneecrusher and a figure-4. Going for that finish early left John Cena open. Great psychology.


On top of that, amazing selling here from Cena that reminded me of his ability to be a great sympathetic babyface. I thought out of the kneecrusher and in the figure-4 he did stupendous. The FU, where he FUs him over the top rope after the figure-4, fighting through the pain and fighting through Batista having the ropes is a beauty. You know Cena is toast and he needs this move if he wants to have a chance at all. It is a great BIG highspot for these two behemoths.

Now they trade comeback routines. In a match structured like this, I love it. It feels big and important. John Cena gets the STFU as a good symmetrical counterpart to Batista's figure-4. Then as he is going for the FU, Batista drops down into a rear naked choke. At first, I loved this counter. It was both sudden and unexpected (never seen Batista use that). Unfortunately, it was quite possibly the worst, loosest "choke" I have ever seen. They tried to zoom in at first you could see that a huge gap between Batista's arm and Cena's neck. They quickly zoom out and try their best to find a shot of this shitty chinlock. The way Cena sells it after it is released is amazing. The choking and he is disoriented. BANG! SPEAR! You are so focused on Cena and then you are totally caught unaware by the spear as is Cena. Loved the suddenness there.

Then use one of the ultimate Clash of the Titans moves...the backward reverse of the powerslam (think of how Sting/Rude reverse the tombstone) and Cena hits an FU out of that! WOW! Cena goes up top they slug it out. Cena goes for that legdrop and eats a Powerbomb. Thought this was the finish given how this is where they say he was injured. Kickout. Wow I bit so hard on that and I popped just like the crowd. Cena eats another BatistaBomb for three.

I dig it. I think the first kick out makes Cena look legitimately strong but they immediately go to the finish which feel definitive. It was an even match all the way. Cena went high risk and he go caught that simple. It was a simple power match that Cena took next level with his selling and each having that superstar presence. One of the best matches of this era and one of the best BIG, Clash of the Titans, Dome type matches of all time. 

#10. Batista vs Shawn Michaels - Backlash 2008

I want someone to watch this match and then look me in the eye and tell me that Shawn Michaels is not a GOAT contender. Goddamn he was fucking awesome in this match. Maybe I am mistaken, but I have never heard anyone talk up this match. I figure it gets overlooked for the phenomenal series between Shawn Michaels and Chris Jericho that this very feud spawns. Before, I get into the match, I want to point out how great of a job they did here with the storytelling. I am an avid fan of soap operas and I think this one of the few times in the last 15 years that WWE really nailed soap opera storytelling. The Ric Flair retirement is a big deal and is going to affect wrestlers in different ways. It was great to spin a feud off of that event. You have Batista who is pissed, almost in mourning, that his mentor is no longer around and it is all Shawn's fault. Shawn says it would have been a disservice to the Nature Boy to let him win. He won the match fair and square and it was time for Nature Boy to ride off into the sunset. Then you have Chris Jericho with his career renaissance as a shit-stirrer, claiming that Shawn is a gloryhound and revels in the fact that he is the man who retired The Greatest of All Time. Then Jericho goes one step further to claim that Batista isn't grieving Ric Flair's retirement, he is angry that he did not get the honor to do it himself. This is great shit! It continued to be amazing throughout the rest of the year. Kudos to all those involved!

There are many facets that make this a great match but I think the one that is the most essential is the grittiness and the amount of struggle in this match. Struggle is something that WWE has lacked throughout its history. WWE matches tend to be every neat. I am in control and then you are in control. Wrestlers don't force their opponents to earn their offense more often than not. I have learned to love other aspects of WWE, but at the end of the day this will be why All Japan or JCP/WCW will always rank ahead of the WWF/E overall. I thought this match had that sense of struggle. That real burning desire to best your opponent in an athletic contest.

On top of that, this is nominally face vs face, which I always think is a very unique and implicitly interesting matchup. It can go in so many directions. You don't know who is going to play the heel in the match and how it will evolve. In addition, I think Shawn Michaels does incredible job playing to Batista's strengths. You mix this all together you arrive at what is match of the year contender for WWE in 2008.

Shawn does a great job early on establishing the power game of Batista. He is trying to attack Batista head on and makes no headway. Batista is shaking him off and just charging. Shawn chop blocks and then switches gear immediately to attack the left arm of Batista. A lot of reviewers would make a point to let you know Shawn and Batista fucked up the initial attempt at the short arm scissors. People make mistakes. We are human. It is how you react to the mistakes that matter. Shawn drives his knee repeatedly into the tricep of Batista. He forces his will on Batista to apply that short arm scissors. In fact it is better that it happened this way because he had to EARN the short arm scissors. If you have ever watched a Shawn Michaels match against Davey Boy Smith, you know why he uses this spot. This spot ultimately to establish the power game of his opponent. Interesting wrinkle here, Batista deadlifts Shawn, but they tumble over the top rope and there is even more wrenching action on the arm. As Batista is selling really well, Shawn shoves him bad arm into the post. After that, it is Dick Murdoch-like clinic on torturing a man's arm. It is tenacious and gritty. Batista is trying to use his power game to regain control, but due to a bad wing, he cant capitalize and Shawn with pitbull determination continues to attack the arm. I loved his hanging armbar over the ropes. This what I am talking about with struggle. Batista is fighting back, but Shawn is fighting through it all. Batista finally string together some power moves like the Samoan Drop and the Oklahoma Slam, but when he lifts up Shawn for the BatistaBomb, his arm fails him and Shawn comes down with the Crippler Crossface. Excellent! I marked out. It was right there when I realized I was watching a classic unfold. Batista makes the ropes and Jericho forcefully yanks Shawn off of Batista. Staredown. They do a great job making Shawn earn his comeback sequence (even though it is not a comeback in this case). Kip-up-SPEAR! Great spot. Shawn knocks Batista off the top and hits the Elbow Drop. Tune up the band and SPINEBUSTER! Loving these hope spots for Batista. One arm Ultimate Warrior rope shake and One Arm thumbs down. Batista is totally committed to selling the arm. Batistabomb, Shawn wriggles free, but twists his knee or perhaps he loses his smile momentarily. :P

Jericho backs Batista off. Michaels gets up and BANG! Sweet Chin Music. Great finish that plays into Jericho's new honest man character that would unveil in the coming weeks. Batista's power game vs Shawn's attack on the arm was a glorious story. Batista sold so well and Shawn was very selfless in establishing Batista's power game that everything melded perfectly. The home stretch was awesome with the big Batista moves stopping Shawn short. Shawn realized even with all his strategizing that Batista's power was too much so he had to dig deep in his bag of tricks and pull out a shady move to get the win. Highly recommended to watch. 

#9. WWE Champion John Cena vs Shawn Michaels - RAW 4/23/07

Shawn Michaels wrestles his ode to the NWA World Championship match without being the World Champion. At first, this kinda miffed me. Why is Cena acting like an upstart challenger. Telling Michaels, he is the close to beating him with the STFU on three occasions or the FU. Then I remember Cena is still being established. Winning the Championship in 2005 is one thing, staying there is another. Cena needs to prove everyone especially the veterans, he is no fluke. I think thats what this match is about. Michaels is not wrestling as Flair or Race. This is not a big bumping performance. This is a subtle heel Jack Brisco or Lou Thesz performance that even his archrival and king of the subtle heel, Bret Hart would be proud of. 

Michaels begins as an aggressive challenger working wristlocks and fireman carrys to try to gain an advantage and each time it is summarily countered almost into STFU, three times to be exact and each time Cena lets HBK know he is this close to beating him. Shawn, frustrated, slaps Cena and Cena responds with a big right hamhock. Thats the end of Act 1. Establishes Cena is not a big, dumb oaf. That he will not be intimidated by the moment or by wrestling. He can counter and is sure of himself. Shawn's opening strategy of taking the fight to Cena almost backfired three times and he needs to switch gears. 

Act II really establishes the Cena power game. This is a much better version of the Butch Reed vs Ric Flair side headlock matches. Cena and Reed have a lot in common in terms of build, presence and offensive ability. One thing that I often am disappointed about in First Wave John Cena (2005-2010) is that he wrestles a Lawler or Savage babyface style meaning he rushes into taking heat and then just makes a triumphant comeback. The shine is so critical in getting the audience invested and fired up. Going right to the heat segment is like going right into the breakdown of a song. This match we really get to see Cena shine and establish that power game. You get the sense of Cena's strength advantage and that HBK is in for a long night. Cena works the headlock, clothesline and shouldertackles well and more importantly Michaels sells it well especially when outside of the hold. I like HBK using roughhouse counters like a reverse elbow sound well by Cena and Michaels sells the damage of the headlock well even at this point. This is not a strong enough transition and Cena hits a big, meaty clothesline. Michaels out of desperation tries for Sweet Chin Music but he is no position to surprise the dominant Champion who evades and hoists Michaels up and almost hits an FU if it was not for the ropes. Thats the end of Act II which is Cena's shine through the power game climaxing with Cena almost hitting the FU. 

Act III as one would expect is when we transition to a heat segment. One issue I have with First Wave Cena (2005-2010) is that he tends to oversell at the beginning of the heat segment. He does not have levels or a gradual way of selling. You would have thought Cena had endured 10 minutes of brutal torture after just a couple Michaels chops. This is unfortunate. A strong transition is what is needed. It turns out that they were not going into heat, but rather Cena was overacting. It is called a register, brutha. Cena uses that power game to catch Michaels and turn into a powerslam, then a Fisherman Suplex and then a Throwback. All gaining minor nearfalls to build the drama. Shawn Michaels hits a swinging neckbreaker which is a lame transition and they lose me going into some Boo/Yay, FIghting Spirit stuff for no reason. Flying Burrito. I guess they are just going for it. Double Count for drama which is good, kip up. Top rope elbow of course, it is too early for Sweet Chin Music so he settles for a backslide, which is odd. Cena misses a shoulder tackle. Now thats a strong transition. Cena takes a hard bump on the mat and skids to the floor.  Michaels shoves Cena into the steel steps to cement his advantage and create a weakness in his arms. I like that Michaels did some of his normal comeback stuff early to make the fans believe this could end at any time and then organically create the hook for the heat segment proper with the shove into the steps. There were some efficiency issues (boo/yay) and Cena overselling issues, but some strong moments. Michaels hitting the big elbow signals to fans this could be over any minute. The Cena missed shouldertackle is a great transition and the steel steps sets up the effective heat segment. 

Act IV does not go as long as I would liked. Shawn did a great job torturing the arm. We werent quite at Dick Murdoch but that is in part due to the fact that it was cut short in my opinion. Shawn varied his attack and Cena did a great job selling. Before you know it we went into the typical Cena comeback sequence. I did like Cena yelling at his arm to fucking shape up before the Fist Drop. He even hit the FU and only two. 

Act V is Cena working the back with big power offense. Running the back into the post, bearhug. As is typical in big Cena matches when the FU fails he hits the Top Rope Leg Drop to the back of the head for two. Michaels gets a sunset flip powerbomb as the playing field is levelled and we enter the last phase of the match. 

Act VI is right after the double count by the ref...Cena goes for the STFU which Lawler lets us know is how Shawn lost at Mania. Good commentary King I had forgotten that. Michaels evades and shoves Cena off the apron onto the announce table. HBK wants to go to for that iconic spot from the Mania match where he piledrives Cena on the steel steps but Cena backdrops him on his bad back. Back in the ring, Cena finally locks in the STFU. Rope break. Good STFU, looked like a choke rather than two forearms across the face. Michaels goes for Sweet Chin Music but Cena has it scouted. Cena wants FU but Michaels creates separation for Sweet Chin Music! He does not cover immediately. Cena needs the ropes to avoid the 3 count. I liked the symmetry between the STFU and Sweet Chin music there. JR telegraphs the finish when he reminds us that this is non-title. I didnt know. As soon as I think I wonder if Michaels wins, he lands on his feet on a FU and BANG! Sweet Chin Music and collapses on top of Cena. 

This is a good representation that wins and losses to a certain extent dont matter. Shawn gets his win back from Mania. Cena never had the rubber match to go up 2-1 but Cena still is a way bigger star than Shawn ever was. Cena is a big star because he won when it mattered most and had a very high winning percentage. My point is that it is not that wins and losses matter or don't matter, it is context and the story being told that matters. The result of the match has long since been forgotten but what is left is a match everyone remembers as a classic. Now it is not like Dolph Ziggler going out proclaiming he is going to steal the show. This is a match where each man is trying to win and the by-product is entertainment as opposed to Ziggler whose goal is to entertain the fans. 

It is weird to call a 55 minute match rushed but it kind of was. I think theres a lot of things they could have flesh out. I think they did a really great job at the beginning. Michaels proved himself to be great at working on top in the 21st Century and I think he could have done more with the arm. I did like the story of Cena pummeling Michaels but Shawn always had a puncher's chance because of Sweet Chin Music. I watched this 2-3 times before and I knew I liked it but didnt think I loved it so I left it off my top 100 WWF/E matches of all time. This match totally belongs up there and I know exactly which match it will replace (Backlund/Valentine October 1981 that finish is dreadful). Awesome NWA Championship style match.

#8. WWE I-C Champion Chris Jericho vs Rey Mysterio - The Bash 2009 Title vs Mask

Even in 2009, Jim Ross occasionally had a good phrase, here he says "Has the nine lives of Rey Mysterio run out?". I think that is a perfect summation of the identity of Rey Mysterio, who as the smaller man in every match has to use high risk offense to stay competitive. When you are wrestling on the edge of a razor you have to be resilient because the high risk offense will be used against or you will crash and burn. I think there is no better wrestler in history at peppering in hope spots than Rey Mysterio. What separates Rey Rey from the spot monkeys is that he allows himself to fail. Some of these high risk moves are going to turned into tilt-a-whirl backbreakers, Codebreakers (what a spot) or the Walls of Jericho. He needs to be resilient enough to withstand that in a kayfabe sense. But in a working sense, he is secure enough in his ability and connection with the crowd that he does not always have to hit his offense and that his moves not always being successful makes for a more compelling match. I will say Rey Rey's selling and bumping is his bread and butter, but I don't think he gets enough credit for his offense and move selection. Jericho was on fire early on, I thought he lost a bit steam towards the end as he was more focused on hitting big spots, but early he was a great dick heel. I loved how he adapted to wrestling Mysterio by playing a big heavyweight. You really felt the weight of Jericho, which you don't usually see. They skipped the shine when Jericho hurled Mysterio into the barricade in a nasty spot. Mysterio always took a nasty fall from the apron on a baseball slide. The way Mysterio sets up his hope spots by creating that separation and then banging a couple off were great and another thing that separates him from the spot monkeys that shoehorn their spots into a match. That is the best split-legged moonsault I have ever seen and I hate the split-legged moonsault. The story of the end of the match was Rey going to live or die by the sword. He would hit a spectacular move only to be caught in a precarious predicament the next moment. It was a great roller coaster ride. It was here I thought Jericho's stellar character work disappeared and Mysterio was generating all the energy. The finish as a great play off their match from the previous month where Jericho swipes Mysterio's mask, but this time Mysterio is wearing another mask and is unphased. He is able to hit 619 and drop the dime.

Fantastic match! Jericho hit out of the park early and when he sort of came down (Jericho was very clean throughout the match, that was in reference to his character work), Mysterio picked up the slack. This is a perfect example of Mysterio's impeccable psychology and breath-taking moves. The finish was roller coaster of drama with Rey Rey looking like he was doomed on several occasions only to prove he can take a lickin' and keep on tickin'.

Rewatched this match because I forgot everything about it. The Codebreaker spot got me again (lol!). I love when I forget a spot and get to mark out all over again. I agree with myself that is the best split-legged moonsault I have ever seen and I still hate the split-legged moonsault.

Things I noticed this time around was that the Rey senton splash to the outside was awesome and a great transition to the mini-Rey comeback. I don't think this was as Rey driven as I said in my previous review. I think Jericho continued to use his weight late into the match. Great catch and powerslam late into the match. I loved the counter to the spinning Argentine Backbreaker which was a great payoff to the previous match. All the Boston Crab counters were money and the crowd was super into them. I loved the powerbomb from the top by Jericho and following up with the feet on the ropes. Really terrific finish stretch. Still a classic. 

I am really excited to watch this a third time because I totally forget the Codebreaker spot again! :P

#7. WWE Champion Randy Orton vs John Cena - Breaking Point 2009 I Quit Match

At first, I was like what is the big deal this is just the usual John Cena vs Randy Orton match. Then Orton started stomping Cena's head on the steel steps. I was like that is pretty violent. Then Orton busted out the handcuffs and cuffed him to the ropes. Well that's definitely escalating thing. Then he hung him up on the post and the match got good, real good. This is the WWE at its cinematographic best. Orton pouring water on Cena so he doesn't pass out. A defiant Cena spitting the water back in Orton's face when he asks him if he quits. Orton whacking Cena as hard as he can with Singapore Canes to the exposed ribs leaving some of the nastiest cuts and bruises on Cena's body. Cena punting him in the balls. This was just great, over the top action movie ass kicking. The verbal selling of Cena was off the charts great in this match. His facial expressions too really captured the agony and helplessness of the situation. Orton did a great job writhing in pain after the ballshot. Orton gets a chair shot to the head and then another one. The way Cena flexes his entire body from the body almost like he is being electrocuted has to go down as one of the single greatest moments of selling in wrestling history. Orton misses with a chair shot and Cena knocks him down. He has the key. Cena cuffs Orton to himself meaning Orton has nowhere to run, nowhere to hide! CENA UNLEASHES THE FURY! We are talking some Jerry Lawler shit right now. WHERE HAS THIS CENA BEEN! These big hammock rights and all the energy this is what Cena should be. Orton does get an RKo as his last gasp. Then he tries to drag Cena to the key. Great drama here with the crowd finally coming alive. Cena ends up overpowering him and wrapping the chain around him such that in the STFU Orton is basically choking himself out. Orton says I Quit!

Beginning of the match being very pedestrian & run of the mill means this is not *****. I thought the finish was good, but could have been great if the metal of the cuff was around Orton's mouth but that's a nitpick. Now let me gush. Cena's selling was truly special. You could argue that he was not selling those Cane shots because they were a fucking shoot. Holy shit! I think the crowd was not reacting because this was not a conventional wrestling match with spots. It was closer to an action movie torture scene. Where Orton had Cena totally helpless and was just torturing him to get him to say I Quit, to break his spirit and rob Cena of his pride. Cena NEVER GIVES UP! They came up with a good way to get Cena the keys and then Cena just DESTROYED Orton! Really unique presentation until pretty much any wrestling match I have ever seen. Kudos!